Mirach | 05/29/09 01:35 pm | 18: CHapter 17 - Balrogs Are Quieter | Signed |
That was a powerful image of Glorfindel at the end of this chapter! And one would almost say that Halbarad did this on purpose to get Aragorn to Rivendell. I would say that I hope he'll survive, but I looked into the next chapters quickly ;) Sorry, but I couldn't resist, as there is no place now where I could leave the story calmly. It's not nice to the readers that must leave for the weekend, you know... :D
Author's Response: LOL... I don't mind you looking ahead at all. *grin* Sometimes you just have to, don't you? I'm glad you liked the imagery with Glorfindel... he was a lot of fun to write through all this. :) Thanks for the review, and hope you survive the weekend! *grin* |
|
Mirach | 05/29/09 08:42 am | 17: Chapter 16 - Go Forth and Fight | Signed |
Ah so, I'm sorry, I thought there should be "hide" (that would make sense, too :). Old English is a bit too much for me...
Author's Response: No problem! Current English is challenging enough, isn't it! LOL But sometimes I do like the feel of an old English word and that one you still hear, a bit tongue-in-cheek usually, in conversation today. |
|
Mirach | 05/29/09 12:51 am | 17: Chapter 16 - Go Forth and Fight | Signed |
After the slower part straight into the action! It looks that Aragorn is far from fine, and getting unreasonable besides that. Good that he's not alone... I found a typo: "you will hie thyself"
Author's Response: Thanks again, Mirach! Yes, you're right... Aragorn is far from fine, most definitely. And it really is just as well, isn't it, that he never has been alone throughout this story, much as I think he might have wanted to be at times. And "hie" isn't a typo... it's 12th century (or thereabouts) English for "hasten" or "go quickly". I don't use too much old English but sometimes there's a phrase that just seems to fit the situation and that was one of them. Thanks for the review! |
|
Mirach | 05/29/09 12:32 am | 16: Chapter 15 - To Windydale | Signed |
I actually wanted to finish this chapter and go to sleep, but the last sentence made me reconsider - if Aragorn can stay awake, so can I :) I admire your care for detail, I would never have the idea to describe the warmth of the saddle, it make the story feel vey realistic. Do you have a horse?
Author's Response: Thank you! I'm glad I kept you up late! No, I don't have a horse, but I've been around them a bit... my friend raises them, and where I live a lot of people have them. And I enjoy reading Westerns! LOL So I've picked up enough knowledge to be dangerous. ;) Thanks for the review! |
|
Mirach | 05/28/09 03:52 pm | 15: Chapter 14 - Ill News | Signed |
Good point with Glorfindel and the bells! :) I wonder that the twins didn't drag Aragorn to Rivendell at once. Loved Halbarad's story :)
Author's Response: Glad you liked this part! I always wondered about those bells on Glorfindel's horse. Thanks for the review! |
|
MP brennan | 05/28/09 03:02 am | 13: Chapter 12 - Time | Signed |
Hello! I'm done with finals, so I finally have time to catch up on one of my favorite stories. I have to say, it's impressive how much of this story has stayed with me. Reading this chap takes me right back into that world, as if I'd just read the first twelve chapters yesterday. That can only be due to the vividness of your writing. This chap was lovely. Poor Aragorn needs a hug and a three week vacation. I love the character development for Denlad. It was funny and poignant at the same time. His awkwardness is adorable and makes a lot of sense; his lifestyle doesn't lend itself to learning much about women. Neala continues to be awesome. The little scene with Bronadui was great. The horse is a character in his own right, which is something you rarely see outside of the "magical animal friend" cliche. Oh, dear. Aragorn knows he needs to go home, but puts it off to avoid the inevitable awkwardness. Something tells me that won't end well, particularly given the mental acrobatics he went through to convince himself he hadn't been touched by the blade. Thanks for another lovely chapter. I look forward to catching up. p.s. Thank you so much for the MEFA nomination!
Author's Response: Thank you and welcome back! :) I know how finals can interrupt important things like reading for fun. LOL Glad you survived them. And of course you are quite welcome for the MEFA nomination... I just love that story of yours. So poignant. Anyway, back to this story. *grin* I'm glad you were able to jump right back into the story--it's always good to hear that a story has stuck with someone, even when it hasn't been fully read! Aragorn really does need a long vacation, doesn't he? But I don't think he gets one for another, um, twenty years? LOL And I'm so glad you like Denlad! I have such a soft spot for him, not least because he's an original character. He'll feature in more stories, so it's always good to know he's striking a chord with readers and not just with me. Yes, I do think your suspicions are right... more troubles ahead for Aragorn. Enjoy (at his expense! LOL) and thanks for the review! |
|
Mirach | 05/21/09 12:24 pm | 14: Chapter 13 - Repercussions | Signed |
I apologize for dissappearing for so long, I was busy with exams, and when I looked at the next chapters quickly, I realized that if I won't stop now, I may not be able to... Ah well, I'll have to learn the names again :) I like this chapter, and the episode with the chains That must be a horrible nightmare about the best friend, maybe the wost that the Nazgul could create,
Author's Response: No need to apologize, Mirach! Real life takes precedences over fanfic, most certainly. I hpe you survived your exams! I'm glad you liked this chapter... I agree in that the Halbarad nightmare has to be, to Aragorn, possibly the worst part of this ordeal, because it would surely force himself to worry that he has some deeply hidden distrust of the man who truly is his confidant and best friend and one to whom Aragorn trusts his life nearly every day. Thank you for the review, and hope you don't have too hard a time with the names! :) |
|
Michelle | 05/08/09 01:10 am | 27: Epilogue - The Year That Followed, Part 2 | Signed |
Umm, you do realize you perfectly set the stage for a sequel here, in which Aragorn and Gandalf go Gollum hunting? Because, personally I'd love to see that! I've read one fanfic about that time and it had just a tiny bit too much geography for my taste (mostly because I'm geography-illiterate, if such a thing is possible). In any case: I'd love to see more of your characters - and I guess the plea for "more" is always the best compliment around. You've made me curious about all of them. Halbarad mostly, of course. But the same is true for Elrond, Glorfindel (which surprised me, to tell you the truth), Erestor and of course Gandalf. He's such a hard character to pin down, because it's so easy to deconstruct his character. So it was interesting to see that you had Aragorn comment on that: that there are moments when he's actually afraid of him. Then again, especially in the chapter where they have that long talk, he's supportive, fatherly almost. All in all, a character with many layers. But the most important of all is Aragorn, naturally. Sticking to his POV provided a fascinating character study, because he's by no means perfect. Rather, you managed to put all his faults under a magnifying glass and still have him come out as a hero. I've no idea how you did it, but it worked! (Maybe it's the fact that his "faults" include things like "puts others first", "doubts himself too much" and "doesn't take care of himself".) Towards the end I did wonder though, whether what the Nazgûl's touch actually did was give Aragorn a clinical depression. It certainly sounds that way. If so, then I really like that analogy! Lastly, thank you for that wonderful tale! I think the quote you chose in the beginning is one of those that just make you stumble while reading, thinking: Come on, tell me more! I want to know what he's alluding to! So thank you for providing a possible explanation. While it wasn't such a fun ride for Aragorn, I certainly enjoyed reading it!
Author's Response: I definitely will be exploring his hunt for Gollum, yes. Probably not in one story, since it is, after all, a sixteen year hunt! Or seventeen or however long it was. Too long for one story to cover, at any rate. But I figure he was back and forth to the east hunting and then home to guard the Shire and several other things along. That part of the canon is relatively blank so a lot could be stuck in there, I think. I just have to sort out what, exactly. :) I'm glad I left you wanting to see more of the characters--that's always a reassuring thing to hear. I absolutely loved writing Gandalf and Glorfindel--in fact, I want to write at least one story of them together, because I don't think it's been done that I know of (not that I know every story out there). I figure since both of them slayed a balrog, they might at least have an interesting conversation in Minas Tirith! I also plan more stories with my original characters involved, as well. It was a bit tricky, doing this tale, to keep Aragorn the strong man he is and yet push him to what I felt was the very edge of what even the "hardiest of living men" could withstand. I'm glad that it all worked well for you in the end. I do think, if they had such terms, "clinical depression" did describe part of Aragorn's troubles, even before the Black Breath hit. Burnout, battle fatigue, depression... whatever you want to call it, I think even a man with great hope could falter in such dark times. But in the end, with the help of his father and his friends, he came out of it stronger than he was before. Interestingly, in talking with a counsellor friend of mine, he said studies are now showing that many people have what they're calling "PTGS"... post-traumatic GROWTH syndrome, where trauma actually ends up strengthening the person. That was exactly what I was going for with Aragorn in this story... he suffered, and will always have that visceral reaction that we see in FOTR at Bree, but in the end, he's stronger for it. Thanks for reading all the way through and leaving all your lovely comments. It was great fun to see your reactions as you went through it! I do have some "extra scene" type tales to post eventually, things I wrote as exercises in character and scene building that *mostly* match what happened in the final version, but like the deleted scenes in movies, have a few things that didn't pan out. Anyway, they'll go in an "Appendice" (yes, borrowing from Tolkien!) First one up will be Elrond's POV during the scenes where he delivers Aragorn from the Black Breath. I'll have that up in a week or so, perhaps sooner if I get it cleaned up. Thanks again for all the reviews! |
|
Michelle | 05/07/09 11:59 pm | 24: Chapter 23 - On the Road of Returning | Signed |
Oh, that's a real treat - putting all these wonderful comfort scenes on a string. Especially the last bit, Aragorn taking Halbarad's hand had me nearly tear up. Yes, sometimes a gesture says more than a thousand words! And I do hope Aragorn learns a valuable lesson from this. I think he truly doesn't agree with Halbarad in the assumption that he risked his life to get to Rivendell. He was so successful in suppressing his own hurts and pains, that at some point he really was convinced that while he was certainly feeling under the weather, nothing was seriously wrong. Sure, some of it was the Black Breath. But some of it was his stupid pride and (as Gandalf put it) his strength of putting others first.
Author's Response: I do think you're right in your assessment... Aragorn's strengths almost set him up for this, because he's the type to always put others first. And the black breath really had a lot to do with the way his mind was messed up. Despair and nightmares are side effects of it, and the nightmares of course lead to sleep deprivation, which leads to fatigue and depression... there are really so many angles to the Black Breath; it was interesting to research it and really examine just what an extensive exposure to it might do to an otherwise very strong man. I'm so glad you enjoyed the scene with Halbarad... that you almost teared up means a lot to me--means I got it right! :) Thanks for the review! |
|
Michelle | 05/07/09 11:42 pm | 23: Chapter 22 - Deliverance | Signed |
Oh, you're too good (for a change *g*) to give your readers another of those wonderful father-son reunions! And this one was even better than the first!
Author's Response: Glad you liked it! I do like the father/son stuff between Elrond and Aragorn, probably because we saw nothing of it in the movies and far too little of it in the books. I need more than the occasional "they parted lovingly" that JRR Tolkien gives us! Thanks for the review! |
|
Michelle | 05/07/09 11:30 pm | 22: Chapter 21 - At hope's Edge | Signed |
Most men would long have died by now. Gee, thank you Gandalf for that comforting thought! It seems, though, as if the adrenaline is finally spent and Aragorn's body has realized how bad it actually feels:)
Author's Response: You're right... it's gotten to the point where even Aragorn realizes things aren't "fine" by any means. And Gandalf does know how to comfort, doesn't he! Thanks for the review! |
|
Michelle | 05/07/09 01:04 am | 21: Chapter 20 - Splintered Fragments | Signed |
"I am fine?" If he really meant to convince Gandalf, he should not have used that particular phrase. Everyone in Middle Earth knows that one should not trust the "I am fine" line. Silly ranger. And please, someone finally knock some sense into him!!
Author's Response: LOL... yes, Aragorn definitely needs some sense knocked into him. And he needs someone to forbid him ever using "fine" again! |
|
Michelle | 05/07/09 12:05 am | 19: Chapter 18 - Ride Through A Nightmare | Signed |
That scene between Aragorn and Elrond was wonderful on so many layers. And of course Halbarad was right and Aragorn had worried without reason. Elrond welcoming him back pratically without words that just screamed the words "a father's love" at me *sighs*. And on an aside, it's really funny to realized that Halbarad and I are the same shopping type. Reluctant and undecided until our best friend pushes us to finally buy the damn thing:)
Author's Response: Thanks, Michelle... I see the Black Breath and his state of mind really working against Aragorn in this story, making him magnify his misconceptions of Elrond's feelings for him. I think under normal circumstances, Aragorn might not have felt so hopeless when it came to Elrond welcoming him back, but part of the Black Breath is despair, and it clouded his thinking. I'm glad you liked the way his return played out. There really wasn't anything Elrond needed to say, was there? And I have to admit, I shop a bit like Halbarad, too! LOL Thanks for the review! |
|
Michelle | 05/06/09 11:47 pm | 18: CHapter 17 - Balrogs Are Quieter | Signed |
Adding some Halbarad angst to the Aragorn angst now, are we? Though, it is a good way to *finally* get Aragorn home without having him protest too much:)
Author's Response: Yeah, poor Halbarad got shot... it was the only way to get Aragorn to Rivendell! LOL |
|
Michelle | 05/06/09 11:12 pm | 16: Chapter 15 - To Windydale | Signed |
Oh, these really are bad news:( You know, I just realized you totally nailed a character I always liked about Aragorn, even if I wasn't aware of it (much). For him, everything is personal. He's not just going around saving people and kicking the villain's butt. He's helping *his* people. People he knows by name, and if he doesn't knows their name he berates himself that he should. Definitely something I like about him, even if that particular character traits gives him nothing but heartache right now!
Author's Response: Thank you, Michelle! I definitely see Aragorn as a hands-on leader, one who knows his people as well as he possibly can, especially his fighting men, and like you say, finds out names of those he doesn't know any time he can. It's one of those characteristics that's both a strength and a weakness for him, because it really can cause heartache. I imagine that might be a problem for him when he becomes King of a much larger realm... no way, probably, for him to really get personal with the people of Gondor. But I bet he tries anyway. ;) Thanks for the review! |
|
|