Tanis06/11/13 03:37 am1: Chapter 1Signed
What an incredible missing scene, or tag, or whatever you want to call it. And while we all know the ending of this story, leaving it at just this place was brilliant. It leaves the reader satisfied, but wanting just a little more.

The tie-in of the fate of our heroes and the stench of that yellow door was brilliantly done as well.

My hat's off to you. You come up with the most engaging scenarios and then bring them exquisitely to life. LOVED this.

ich bins05/16/13 06:35 pm1: Chapter 1Signed

Brilliant gap filler! You really are exceedingly skilled in describing feelings and creating atmosphere. Aragorn's fears and feelings were so "contagious", I am just glad, that I know there will be a happy end. You had to end before Aragorn learns that too, hadn't you?

Okay, that sounded to unhappy, I like the point you endet the story, it was just perfect there and I love your last sentence. I'm not always sure what I should make of very amplified and fabulous wordingings in a story. However, you achieve it, that you have a middle-earth-fit style, which seems at some points (and always the right ones, like this last sentence) even poetric, but there are never too-excessive embellishments... What I mean is... I like your stile and your last sentence and the picture which it draws and that it is hopefull last sentence (for those who know). 

I know there is a close bond between Aragorn and Frodo, but I think I have hardly red anything about it. Your story shows it wonderfully. And again you have catched Aragorn perfectly, I think. He just made a great victory and yet he is not resting (which he sould, as I know he is going to heal some people soon) or celebrating but worrying about Frodo and Sam.

And I like the title. (I think I got it this time, at least enough of its meaning, that I can really appreciate it. [Thanks for the explanation last time, it was really interesting.])

Excellent story!



Author's Response:

Thanks for the wonderful review!  Yes, I had to end on an angsty note because I'm evil like that.  ;-)  I'm glad you enjoyed this story all the same.

I'm glad you enjoyed the language in this story.  Writing in Tolkien fandom is always a balancing act; simplify the language too much and it can sound too modern, embellish too much and it can end up sounding pretentious.  I tend to fiddle with the wording a lot, so it's good to hear that the style for this story worked in the end.

Thank you for all your support!

-Brennan


Ellynn05/11/13 05:51 pm1: Chapter 1Signed

Such a poignant story. I like that you finished it before the moment when Aragorn finds out good news.



Author's Response:

Thanks for the lovely review!

-Brennan


You must login (register) to review.