Michelle05/20/13 02:17 pm12: Epilogue: For PeaceSigned

I've enjoyed this story so very much!! I've had so little time lately to read fanfic (let alone longer stuff), so this story put me right back into the mood why I love LOTR fic. I could read endlessly about Aragorn's adventures in far-off countries, but that you decided to tell the story from Hakim's point of view gave the fic an interesting twist. And of course, the moment when he finally realizes that the King is actually Dakheel was priceless. I was basically cheering:)



Author's Response:

Thank you for the wonderful review!  This was my first time writing in one of the "far-off countries," and it was both more rewarding and way more of a challenge than I was expecting.  I'm so glad you enjoyed the finished product!

 

-Brennan


babschwi05/02/13 10:55 pm12: Epilogue: For PeaceAnonymous

I have not much to say, after the brilliant review from Ellyn and Ichbins - they said it all. So, thank you very much for a wonderful story and I'm looking forward to the sequel! It is really sad, that some stories must come to an end.



Author's Response:

Thank you so much!  I hope future works live up to your expectations.

-Brennan


ich bin's05/02/13 08:31 pm12: Epilogue: For PeaceAnonymous

A condign end for a brilliant story. I hate that it is over and that you don't let me "watch" the meal of Aragorn, Hakim and his son, but I think it is (unfortunately) the right ponit to end. I am glad it was a happy end, I had always thoght there would be a happy end, but I sometimes shook with nerves in sympathy for your OCs and Aragorn. (You didn't made it easy for them.) In this chapter (for the firsth time in this story) Aragorn's behavior was somehow strange to me, you explained it well, so that it was in line with Aragorn's charakter well enough, but I cannot imagine his little "show" with Hakim has had that much impact on the Lords. However, he is much more wise than me, so probably it did ;-) Anyways, I somehow liked feeling the tension that was nearly visible in this room and feeling the shakiness Hakim probebly felt, altogh he did great. Oh, and I liked Aragorn's speek and the irony of this one Lord talking about stubborn people who wouldn't change their ways. The sad thing is, that this (like your entire text) is so realistic. Stubborn people complaining about stubborn people, war-used people afraid of peace and people in war afraid of each other (and may hating each other) to much to even think rational... this could have played in nowadays world as well - which is another reason to love your story. Not that every story must have a moral or lesson - your story is defenitly worth reading it, just because it is so exciting and your OCs are so great and Aragorn is so true to himself - but that it could set in this world as well (instead of middle-earth) with little changes is a great bonus.

I might write confused, what I need to say is: Thank you very much for a wonderful story. I love it!

And I look forward to the sequel.



Author's Response:

Thank you so much for one more wonderful review!  I'm glad you enjoyed this wrap-up.  Yes, Aragorn gets a little theatrical here--perhaps overly so.  This was a whole new role for him, and to an extent I wanted him to seem "strange"--to Hakim and to the reader.  He's still feeling out his new political role, so to an extent, he's even strange to himself.  Sadly, you might be right that the effects of his display weren't as great as he probably hoped.  He's starting to change people's minds, but it will be a long process.  This was just the opening salvo.  But, that's a whole 'nother story!  ;)

Thanks again for your thoughtful reviews!

-Brennan


Ellynn05/02/13 09:15 am12: Epilogue: For PeaceSigned

Well, my only objection to this epilogue is that it's too short! Yes, yes, I know, it's only epilogue, and right now Aragorn has other duties so he can't chat with an old friend, but nevertheless, I wish this was longer!

Thank you for this wonderful journey.



Author's Response:

I was so tempted to make this longer and to include all the conversations with old friends catching up . . . I had to resist, though, to keep the tone I wanted.  I'm toying with the idea of writing a sort of "appendix" to this story with those kinds of "deleted scenes."

Thank you for all your support along the way!

-Brennan


Ellynn04/29/13 11:53 am11: Be All My Sins RememberedSigned

Yes, while still reading, I wondered if you'd describe Aragorn's adventures. :)

I like the chapter, especially the last part. There is not much happening - only Hakim's general description of the events, but I love the way you did it. There is some special melancholic, sad tone in it that I like.



Author's Response:

Thanks for reviewing!  I'm glad you liked the tone, especially towards the end.  I hope you enjoy the final wrap-up to this tale.

-Brennan


babschwi04/28/13 11:38 pm11: Be All My Sins RememberedAnonymous

Thank you so much for a beautiful written story! 'Ich bins' review said it all. I especially liked the part about the rumors coming up from the south, showing very clear that Dakheel was alive and 'making a difference'. Looking forward to your update and the next story.



Author's Response:

Thank you so much for reviewing!  I'm glad you enjoyed the part about the rumors.  I went back and forth about how much detail to include for those.  Hope you enjoy the conclusion and the sequel!

-Brennan


ich bin's04/28/13 05:47 pm11: Be All My Sins RememberedAnonymous

Thoroughly great chapter! (Even though you let us wait once again for a talk or something between Aragorn and Hakim, how could you?!) You put the story strings well together.

It somehow made me feel really good, that Hakim tried to free Aragorn, but he didn't want to. I somehow expected, that he would be sold, but able to flee afterwards, however that is so much better. Now we see Hakim finding the strenght and heart to help Aragorn - not in impulse, but knowing what it might bring to him and that he is acting against his fathers wish - and we see Aragorn being a strong hero, who does all this willingly (more or less) for his aim, rather than a broken man who get forced to be a slave. Oh, I cannot even tell you how much confort this means to me (probably to Hakim as well^^). But I don't want to get obsessed with this topic, as there are so much other great things I have to praise. 

I like how you told us, what happend after they seperated. You didn't tell us to much about Hakim, yet we know what is important (for the story) and you told it well. And how you told us about Aragorn (even thogh it was probably hard, because Hakim is the narrator and he doesn't know to much) was very well solved. I can sy myself, that Aragorn did well, but you didn't force Hakim to be there and see something or do something else unrealstic. (But I would love to hear more about Aragorn's time with the slaves, I will keep an eye on your profile) Oh, and how you put in how Hakim gets the sword and Aragorn gets his stuff back was very well done too.

And there, as well as in the other chapters (but I think I forgot to mention it last time) are so much especially good sentences, said by Aragorn or Hakim. I feel that in this chaptere there are more of them than before, wise and somehow grave statements which gave a tone of...severity especially to this chapter, at least at parts. And we could see Hakim's development pretty good. At firsth he was more or less a boy, keen but ingenuous, but when Aragon leaves he understands a great lot and has somehow matured. We see it in the way he acts and talks and it has influence on the style of the story, because he is telling it, and I think it's great how you captured this. Also the difference of the way "old Hakim" is seeing and describing his surroundings and the way "young Hakim" (especially at the beginning) is seeing the world is pretty good worked out. There is no to big gap, as it is still the same person and he is making the narration now in form of recollections, but you can get a difference (or I am imagine it, which is just as fine as long as I like it ;-)

 

I'm looking forward to the epilogue and to more stories! (I think I could read thousands of this/your stories...)



Author's Response:

Thank you so much for another wonderful review!

I'm glad you enjoyed the resolution.  It was very important to me that Aragorn choose his eventual fate.  I don't see him as the kind of character who would tolerate having his agency taken away . . . but he might choose to lay it down in service of a greater good.  I'm glad you appreciated Hakim's character development as well.  It was kind of subtle, but I tried to shape the story around the idea of Hakim coming of age and becoming aware of the greater complexities of the world.

I hope you enjoy the epilogue and my future works!  I'm not sure if I have *thousands* in me, but there are a few kicking around in my head.

-Brennan


ich bin's04/26/13 08:59 am10: Desperate HeartsAnonymous

What a great story!

Your OCs are great, they are all so... "lifelike". Most stories with people from Harad have just the "evil" Harads and maby or one or two "heroic victims" of their own people. Your charakters are neither oft that. They are not perfect, but not bad either. I like how the mother acts and how her attitude towards "the foreigner" chances. I like the father and how in-depth his charakter is - knowing his desperation and his "good sides", you do not see him just as evil person, even thogh it is still no excuse for selling somebody (even the word selling sounds incredibly worng here). I like Hakim an I like reading his thoghts about everything and especially about Aragorn (and I like, that he became healer- if I got that right- he should tell Elessar^^). And I think I like Kali most, even thogh we do not know that much about her, as she is still so little, but you described her acting well and she is cute. Somehow I feel as if this whole family were real.

You (and/or Hakim) also described Aragorn great. Seeing him through the eyes of an Haradrim is really interessting and Aragorn's acting and speeking (heroic, but not superhuman) is how I always imaginated him (which is very importent to me).

The content is also very good. You show us perspectives of Harad, which we didn't had and tell us a little bit more about Aragorn, but mostly you tell the story of a family and especially a youg boy, finding himself in a situation none thoght he/they would ever be and that is maybe changing a lot. Even thogh the situation in Harad is not that good at the moment it was enjoyable to read about this family and thrilling. And there is this "other" little story about Hakim in Gondor and it is a really exciting story and how you put that together with the flashbacks and so on was great.

Oh, I have been fevered waiting for the moment they meet and recognice each other, even thogh I wanted the story to last as long as possible. I could have read so much more about Aragorn there. But I think you chosed a good story length nevertheless.

What I wanted to tell you with this terribly long Reviw is: I love your story! (I could have just wrote that, but now you know or sure that everything is great.) 

I can't wait for Sunday, I want to read about them talking and... oh, I'm so agog. 

Kind regards from Austria! (where I come from, which is the reason for the bad English, sorry by the way)

Until the next chapter;-)



Author's Response:

Thank you for the awesome review!  It had me grinning from ear to ear.  I'm so glad you enjoyed the OCs and found them life-like!  They were my biggest concern going into this, since they carry so much of the story and I've never written so much with original characters before.  My beta (the poor woman) can attest to this; for weeks, I was spamming her inbox with "does this sound okay?  what about this?  would anybody even want to read this?"  But, once it started flowing, I had a lot of fun with just letting the characters do their thing and insert ambiguity into the story.  I'm glad you enjoyed the family and their evolution over the course of the story.  And Kali might be my favorite too.  ;)

 

I'm glad you enjoyed the plot as well, even though some of it is a bit dark.  Believe me, I also cringed every time I had to use the word "slave" or "selling" but the story seemed to demand it.  I'm glad you liked the pacing and that the suspense came through.

 

I hope you enjoy the rest of the story!  Sunday's chapter will be the last "regular" installment while the epilogue that follows will deal mostly with the Gondor storyline.  Thank you so much for the incredibly kind review!

 

-Brennan


babschwi04/25/13 11:46 pm10: Desperate HeartsAnonymous

I can hardly believe you can solve this fine story in only one last chapter. To me you can write on and on and....



Author's Response:

:)  Thanks for the vote of confidence!  I thought about making this longer, but I find I do better when I limit myself to somewhat focused storylines.  This is the longest I've allowed myself to ramble on in some time.  And while there's definitely more that could be said about Aragorn and his travels in Harad, it's nearly time for Hakim's part of the story to wrap up.  I hope you enjoy, nonetheless!

 

-Brennan


Ellynn04/25/13 09:31 am10: Desperate HeartsSigned

This is great. I can't wait for Sunday!



Author's Response:

Thank you!  I hope you enjoy the conclusion!

 

-Brennan


babschwi04/23/13 09:58 am9: The Burning KingAnonymous

very good written !

'This king of theirs seems to have a lot of names.'  lol

Poor Hakim, seeing his friend chained and unable to comfort or help. No wonder he thought he was crying.

And so very true of Aragorn to spend comfort even in a miserable position.

Hope you update soon, can hardly wait to read further...



Author's Response:

Thank you for the wonderful review!  Ha, I can't seem to stop myself from commenting on his overabundance of names!  And Hakim doesn't know the half of it . . .

 

-Brennan


Ellynn04/15/13 12:51 pm7: And See Each Other's FaceSigned

I knew it! I knew Kalima's wound would get worse because her mother had stitched it! Ok, ok, "things can go wrong anyway", as Aragorn politely put it, but we know the reason for the problems that appeared, don't we?

I read this chapter "in one breath", as we say in Croatian.



Author's Response:

Thanks for the review!  I'm so glad this chapter drew you in.

Yeah, it's generally a bad idea to stitch a dog bite.  We do it occasionally here in the wacky world of veterinary medicine, but we have antibiotics.  Asima meant well, though.

Hope you keep reading!

-Brennan


Amarok04/10/13 07:53 pm6: And Are We Yet AliveAnonymous

Wow..., I just love this story. It's written in a great way, Aragorn is wonderfully strong and wise, and the family members are all real characters, very believable and likeable. Also I love that there are two tracks of action and am curious how it will come togehter in the end. Looking very much forward to the next chapters...



Author's Response:

Thank you!  I'm so glad you're enjoying this story so far.

 

-Brennan


babschwi04/08/13 11:56 am5: Dark TalesAnonymous

'Dakheel turned slightly green.  I laughed softly.  Foreigners had such strange ideas about food.'  I just can repeat myself... this is so well written! And the tension is building from chapter to chapter. I can hardly wait to read more and what will happen.  

 

 



Author's Response:

:)

Thank you!  I hope you like where this story goes.

-Brennan


Ellynn04/05/13 10:48 am4: The Empty MenSigned

It is really sad, and shocking, and terrible, what one "human being" can do to another.

Excellent writing, as always. ;)



Author's Response:

Yes, I went into rather a dark place with this chapter.  I thought it was important, for this story, that the evil deeds be committed by Men (rather than orcs/Nazgul/fantasy-villain-of-your-choice) since humans really are capable of atrocities for all kinds of reasons.

I hope you keep reading despite the bleak moments.

-Brennan


You must login (register) to review.