Ragnelle09/12/12 01:08 pm2: The Coming of SpringSigned

I meant to review this some time ago, and then it slipped my mind.

This version of the chapter is so much easier to follow than the first version: a really great rewrite there!

It seems to me like Aragorn is sufferening from depression here, and have not been able to think straight because of it. Good to see him (partly) come to his senses. Of course he can visit his North Kingdom from time to time! In fact, he should.

I was confused by the "It's supposed to be blasted cold" comment from Aragorn, though. He lived a fair amount of his life in the North: he should know what it is like in winter from experience. Not that Arnor is that far north: the Shire is supposed to be on the lattitue of England. (If I remember corectly, Hobitun is about the same lattitue as Oxford. Don't quote me on that before I have found the reference, though.)



Author's Response: This is going to be a rather short reply, because I'm writing on my smartphone and it takes such time... My computer is broken -.- But I'm so glad to hear this version was better! I like it more too,and I enjoyed writing it as well. :) About Arnor... In my head it's much farther from the Shire than it actually is. I think what he should have been saying is the north of Arnor - ot would not have sounded good in the text, but that is very far north. I read Gondor is on the same latitude as Florence, and if the Shire is on the same as Oxford that makes the ME map huge. I can't remember if it was still occupied when Aragorn lived but I think it was a dark place where no one lived, so maybe not even the rangers had been deep into Arnor. Now it became long anyway... I just had to explain so I wouldn't be completely wrong.^ Thanks for reviewing anyway! Hopefully I can keep this standard in the following chapters;)

Ragnelle05/12/12 01:32 pm1: The Wistle of the WrenSigned

I like this beginning. It promises an entertaining story. While I think Aragorn is rigth in that he can't really disapear, being king and all, that level of realism is not allways needed. It is enough that the story is entertaining ;)

One small thing, though. All the contractions were really distracting. It is not that I object to anyone in ME using contractions at all-- that can be as distracting as well-- here it became too much for me. It might have something to do with the set-up of this archive, but the end result were that I was constantly drawn out of the story because of them. And that was annoying.



Author's Response:

I'm glad you like it, and I hope I can live up to your expectations! I have worked a lot to make it realistic because I usually prefers it that way, but that doesn't mean, of course, that everything has to be logic. I think that while Aragorn has to have some reason to not think he is able to disappear, it doesn't have to be impossible, simply because he's a human and humans are not always very logical thinkers. And of course, if a story is entertaining enough you can take some unrealism. It's fantasy after all! :)

You're right, I did use a lot of contractions in this chapter. I use them because I want a sort of everyday feeling in the text, but, of course, it can become too much. English is not my first language whcih means I don't always notice these things - so thanks for pointing out! It helps, and I'll think of it in the next chapter. (One reason might be I've been using the acute accent ´ instead of ' which makes a much bigger gap in the text. I'm trying to teach myself to do it right!)


babschwi05/05/12 12:32 am1: The Wistle of the WrenAnonymous

Oh, please, go on. So far I like it and it sounds very promising. And I am waiting for the next chapter.



Author's Response:

Yay, thank you! :D Next chapter will hopefully be up in a couple of days!


You must login (register) to review.